Skip to content

Under Pressure: Randy Carlyle

Aug 25, 2014, 12:21 PM EDT

Randy Carlyle AP

“If you’re worried about optics in this market, it’s going to be a disaster. I think you have to make a decision based on what you think is the best decision for the organization, and this in our minds was clearly the best option.

“He was a guy we believe can get the job done for us. Whether optics are that it’s the wrong thing to do or not doesn’t really matter to us. If you’re looking at trying to please people, you’re probably going to make some poor decisions.”

That was Toronto GM Dave Nonis this past May, talking about the decision to extend head coach Randy Carlyle. The move came under heavy fire as the optics of retaining Carlyle, who presided over a Leafs team that went 2-12-0 down the stretch and collapsed out of playoff contention, left many scratching their heads. Several other coaches that whiffed on the playoffs met their demise — John Tortorella, Adam Oates and Barry Trotz, to name a few — and Nonis made it clear there was some issue at the coaching level by turfing all three of Toronto’s assistants.

Yet when the dust settled, Carlyle remained. One of the few constants in an offseason filled with change.

The Leafs really shifted course this summer. They hired a new president, Brendan Shanahan, then emerged as progressive club on the advanced analytics front — first, with the hiring of 28-year-old assistant GM Kyle Dubas, known as a fancy stat advocate with OHL Sault Ste. Marie; then, with the creation of an advanced numbers department, spearheaded by the guy that used to run Extra Skater.

Change happened on the ice, too.

Gone, it seems, are the day of trotting out truculent bottom-six forwards like Colton Orr and Frazer McLaren. Toronto had itself a Moneyball-esque summer, signing (slightly) flawed veterans on the cheap in the hope of striking gold — guys like former 30-goal scorer David Booth (signed for $1.1M after getting bought out of a disastrous situation in Vancouver), skilled center Mike Santorelli (inked for $1.5M after last season was cut short by season-ending shoulder surgery) and power forward Daniel Winnik (who fell out of favor in Anaheim, remained unsigned ’til August, then came to Toronto for $1.3M). These additions, along with Finnish forwards Petri Kontiola and Leo Komarov, should give Toronto the most depth it’s had up front in the Carlyle era.

As such, the pressure is on.

By keeping Carlyle after last year’s collapse, the message was loud and clear — this was on the players, not the coach. But from that point forward, the challenge was put on everybody to achieve more, coaches included. Expectations have been heightened and there is a demand for improvement — for example, Toronto could have a wildly competitive training camp, as there are 15 forwards on NHL contracts fighting for 12 spots.

All of this, of course, comes back to Carlyle, who has now been given tools to succeed: new players, new assistants and a new, fresh look at the managerial level. If that pressure wasn’t obvious enough, Nonis ensured it in May by saying his coach needs to get through to this group.

“If you’ve seen it being done before with most of the same players, or a lot of the same players, and with that coach leading that group, I know it can happen,” said Nonis. “I know it has happened with this group before. I know that (Carlyle) has reached them before, reached them at times this year.

“For me it’s not that we’re guessing whether or not he can have success or he can get through to them. We’ve seen it. I know that it’s there and we feel he is the guy that can get through to this group.”

  1. lowenni - Aug 25, 2014 at 12:41 PM

    I don’t think Carlyle is a bad coach. That being said–I also don’t think he is the right fit for the maple leafs. The Leafs have become a skating, skill team, highlighted by guys like Kessel, Kadri, Gardiner’s, Reilly, etc. Now, obviously not the whole team is like this, but a team swings as its top players do. When Carlyle won the Cup with the Ducks it was a big, big heavy team. Obviously Carlyle’s leash is going to be very short this year in Toronto and if he can’t figure out how to improve the teams puck possession and utilize the skill and skating ability of the team he’ll be gone before the halfway mark of the season.

  2. bsaures - Aug 25, 2014 at 1:36 PM

    I give him to about the all star break if they arent in a comfortable playoff spot he will likely be gone

  3. dueman - Aug 25, 2014 at 2:08 PM

    I think that Carlyle’s job relies heavily on whether or not, Babcock resigns in Detroit…

  4. canuckinamerica - Aug 25, 2014 at 2:49 PM

    See ya, Dave.

  5. clpalermo94 - Aug 26, 2014 at 7:00 AM

    Randy is shanahans fall guy.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Rinne (1228)
  2. S. Bennett (1223)
  3. D. Alfredsson (1212)
  4. D. Kuemper (1190)
  5. J. Drouin (1164)