Skip to content

Players need to ask themselves: Is it worth it?

Oct 30, 2012, 1:15 PM EST

Fehr and players

Even after the NHL canceled all games through November, NHLPA chief Donald Fehr maintained it makes sense for the players to hold out for a better deal from the owners.

“It’s a five-or-six-or-seven-year agreement,” Fehr told the StarTribune Monday. “Also, look at what’s on the table [from the owners], there’s a lot more that’s on the table in addition to just player share. They’re saying the things players got in the last agreement in return for the 24 percent rollback [and salary cap], they have to take it back. [The players] lose ground in salary arbitration, they lose ground in free agency, lose ground in the entry-level system, contracts are limited in all kinds of ways that make them much less secure.”

However, when asked if it would make sense to lose an entire season of salary – in 2011-12, total player compensation was $1.873 billion – Fehr would only say that the league stands to lose an entire season of revenue, too.

The counter-argument is that an NHL franchise isn’t an NHL player. The first has an indefinite life span and a value that’s determined by the expectation of future revenues; the other has an average career length of four to five seasons and a value that falls to zero once that career is over.

In September, Mike Modano reflected on the season the players lost due to the 2004-05 lockout.

“At some point, we were sold a bill of goods,” Modano told ESPN. “Everybody was buying it. Everybody thought, ‘Let’s not let each other down. Let’s do it for the future of the game. Blah, blah, blah.’ You’re only in the game so long.”

And he wasn’t the only one to look back in regret.

Last November, Dave Andreychuk advised locked out NBA players to get a deal done as soon as possible: “In the end, it will be worse.”

Last October, Bill Guerin concluded: “Burning a year was ridiculous.”

So is Fehr doing the players a disservice by advising they hold out for a better deal that he’s not even guaranteed to deliver? Sure, the NHLPA – which like an NHL franchise has an indefinite life span – may be stronger in the long run by standing up to the owners today, but if you’re a current player, how much are you willing to sacrifice for the future of the cause?

Only the players can answer those questions. Perhaps money isn’t the root cause of their dispute with the NHL. Maybe it’s more about pride and fairness. Nobody likes to be extorted, even if paying the ransom is preferable on a non-emotional level to the alternative.

Fehr said he reminds the players “a negotiation is a process of constant reevaluation.”

So, do they stay the course?

Or, is it time to…reevaluate?

Latest Posts
  1. Welcome Patrik Berglund to the trade rumor mill

    Nov 26, 2014, 1:03 PM EST

    Patrik Berglund AP

    The Blues are one of the few teams in the NHL with a surplus of quality centers.

  2. With Elliott hurt, Blues make emergency goalie recall

    Nov 26, 2014, 12:57 PM EST

    Brian Elliott Brian Elliott

    Jordan Binnington on his way up to St. Louis.

  3. The day before Thanksgiving, six new playoff teams

    Nov 26, 2014, 12:22 PM EST

    Josh Bailey, John Tavares, Travis Hamonic AP

    What are the chances the Islanders, Leafs, Predators, Canucks, Flames and Jets can hang on?

  4. Calgary waives Setoguchi

    Nov 26, 2014, 12:11 PM EST

    Calgary Flames v Nashville Predators Calgary Flames v Nashville Predators

    Fall from grace for the former 30-goal scorer.

  5. Not a repeat: Pens lose Bennett to injury, again

    Nov 26, 2014, 11:42 AM EST

    WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 20: Beau Bennett #19 of the Pittsburgh Penguins skates down the ice against the Washington Capitals at the Verizon Center on November 20, 2013 in Washington, DC. Getty Images

    Out “a couple of weeks” with a lower-body injury.

  6. No hearing scheduled for Hanzal after Johnson hit

    Nov 26, 2014, 11:28 AM EST

    HanzalJohnson

    Arizona forward forced the Avs d-man from the game.

  7. No hearing scheduled for Garbutt after kneeing Hall

    Nov 26, 2014, 11:10 AM EST

    GarbuttHallKnee

    Dallas forward does have a history with the NHL’s player safety department.

  8. NHL on NBCSN: Flyers face Red Wings on Rivalry Night

    Nov 26, 2014, 10:50 AM EST

    Jakub Voracek, Jonas Gustavsson, Niklas Kronwall AP

    Two teams headed down different paths?

  9. Shaw returns to Blackhawks’ lineup tonight

    Nov 26, 2014, 10:03 AM EST

    Winnipeg Jets v Chicago Blackhawks Getty Images

    He missed the last three games with an upper-body injury.

  10. Are the Jets and Coyotes being too loyal to their starting goalies?

    Nov 26, 2014, 9:16 AM EST

    Arizona Coyotes v Vancouver Canucks Getty Images

    It’s a question that could decide a playoff spot or two.

  11. Ducks aren’t sure how severe Beauchemin’s upper-body injury is

    Nov 26, 2014, 8:51 AM EST

    Anaheim Ducks v Dallas Stars Getty Images

    Tough start to the season for the veteran defenseman.

  12. Avs erase 3-0 deficit to edge Coyotes 4-3

    Nov 26, 2014, 2:00 AM EST

    Colorado Avalanche v Nashville Predators Getty Images

    Colorado has now won four of five.

  13. Report: Perron could be headed to Columbus

    Nov 26, 2014, 12:45 AM EST

    davidperrongetty Getty Images

    Jackets and Oilers talking trade.

  14. Video: Hanzal with an elbow to the head of Erik Johnson

    Nov 26, 2014, 12:05 AM EST

    Martin Hanzal Getty Images

    The Avs’ defenseman left the game and did not return.

  15. Video: Stars’ Garbutt hits Hall knee-on-knee

    Nov 25, 2014, 11:25 PM EST

    St. Louis Blues v Dallas Stars St. Louis Blues v Dallas Stars

    The Oilers’ forward has had his share of knee injuries.

  16. Video: Canucks honor Quinn with “O Danny Boy”

    Nov 25, 2014, 10:29 PM EST

    patquinn

    Spent time in Vancouver as a player and a coach.

Featured video

Eakins on his way out of Edmonton?

Sign up for Fantasy hockey

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Datsyuk (2623)
  2. V. Hedman (2473)
  3. P. Sharp (2402)
  4. S. Crosby (2298)
  5. D. Krejci (1981)
  1. B. Marchand (1939)
  2. Z. Chara (1884)
  3. B. Dubinsky (1788)
  4. A. Tanguay (1566)
  5. S. Varlamov (1555)