Skip to content

Focus group fallout: When does enough become enough for the NHL?

Oct 16, 2012, 11:50 AM EDT

Gary Bettman AP

The latest PR disaster for the NHL – as if yet another work stoppage wasn’t tarnishing its image enough – came Monday when it was revealed by Deadspin that a focus group had been commissioned by the league to gauge fan reaction to various lockout-related issues.

The focus group – led by well-known political consultant and Republican strategist Frank Luntz – asked participants to, among other things, read lists of statements and answer which ones made them feel most negative about the owners, or which ones were the most persuasive in justifying the lockout, or which ones were most disappointing about the lockout.

The intent of the focus group was obvious: The NHL wanted to know the best way to sell the lockout to the fans.

Deputy commissioner Bill Daly confirmed to that the league regularly does “polling and focus groups on issues impacting the league, as do other sports leagues. It’s part of our normal business practices.”

But most will argue there’s a difference between assembling a focus group for marketing purposes (e.g, “What do you like most about the NHL playoffs?”) and PR purposes.

And while some have tried to justify the league’s use of focus groups, even in this particular case, the overwhelming reaction to the Deadspin story has been negative.

The question is, has it been negative enough to soften the league’s position against the NHLPA and, in turn, help resolve the lockout?

We ask in large part due to the NFL’s experience during its recent referees lockout. In that case, a badly blown call by the replacement officials on Monday Night Football was considered to have embarrassed the league to the point it had no choice but to bring back the regular refs.

Not to suggest NHL commissioner Gary Bettman is taking as much flak for the Deadspin story as NFL commissioner Roger Goodell took for the replacement officials. The blown call in the Monday Night Football game was international news.

But Bettman is still taking some serious flak, the Deadspin story just the latest storm of controversy. Jim Devellano’s infamous “cattle” comment was another black eye for the NHL.

Bettman is used to the criticism and he knows it’s part of the job, but at some point enough has to become enough.

Whether we’re at the tipping point yet, or even close to it, is still to be seen.

The NHL and NHLPA are meeting today in Toronto.

  1. fortwaynekomets - Oct 16, 2012 at 12:05 PM

    Bettman doesnt care about the future of the sport. All he cares about is being greedy and making money. This is sad, but Bettman wont be around in 50 years to see the game of hockey (what’s left of it), he just cares about his percentage of the pie.

    Only problem is us FANS are eating that pie away very fast, while not spending 1 cent on Hockey related material!

    Also, as many people have stated, after the last lockout the fans showed overwhelming support and hockey became stronger than ever. Bettman is banking on this happening again.

  2. gregman98 - Oct 16, 2012 at 12:26 PM

    Correction to your story Jason (re: the last sentence):

    They’re actually meeting in Toronto today, not NY.

    • Jason Brough - Oct 16, 2012 at 12:34 PM

      Thanks. Changed.

  3. biffnasty - Oct 16, 2012 at 12:53 PM

    why do i think gary buttman does not care whatsoever what the paying, loyal fans think. i seriously do not know how this clown still has a job. he has done nothing for the sport

    • blomfeld - Oct 16, 2012 at 1:40 PM

      “he has done nothing for the sport” …

      On the contrary friend. Gary Bettman has overseen a revenue surge from 2.0 billion dollars to 3.3 billion dollars in just the past 6 years. That is actually “something” in my books. :)

  4. davebabychreturns - Oct 16, 2012 at 1:10 PM

    Honestly I think the “PR battle” is really overblown.

    It’s something for us all to talk about but if this labour dispute was truly being fought in the newspapers (and on blogs and on the radio) then known hardasses like Bettman and Fehr would be orchestrating things from the background.

    You can say that’s happening to some extent – and trotting out Bill Daly to talk to the press is certainly a concession to the fact that even Bettman knows how unsympathetically he is viewed – but at the end of the day the two head honchos have their hands all over this situation.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Kane (1430)
  2. P. Kessel (1386)
  3. M. Boedker (1220)
  4. S. Matthias (1147)
  5. R. McDonagh (1134)