Skip to content

On the subject of replacement players

Oct 2, 2012, 12:14 PM EDT

Replacements Getty Images

On the one hand, it would further damage the reputation of the NHL.

On the other, just think of the comedy!

Monday night on Josh Rimer’s radio show, former Leafs assistant GM Bill Watters speculated that league commissioner Gary Bettman could bring in replacement players – possibly by mid-November – in an attempt to break the union and end the lockout.

Some in the media are skeptical.

But it’s not the first time Watters has touched on the subject of replacements.

“There are enough free agents around and players under contract in junior, on reserve lists and in the AHL to ice a team in every city,” he told the Toronto Sun in September. “It is conceivable. It wouldn’t be a long-term thing but a union breaking move.”

OK, first question: Would that even be legal? Surely there are labor laws that cover this sort of thing. Replacement players have been used before in sports, but we imagine it took a few lawyers to usher them in.

Next question: Assuming the NHL finds a way to jump through all the legal hoops, what kind of player would cross the picket line and be willing to wear the “scab” label the rest of their careers?

Perhaps…

—- A fringe player who knows he’s not good enough to make the NHL except as a replacement.

—- A veteran that’s on the verge of retirement and has nothing to gain from a lost season.

—- A player with a beef against the union.

Sounds like a fantastic product.

It’s also worth wondering if this sort of move could seriously backfire for the NHL. We all saw what happened when the NFL attempted to use replacement officials. The product suffered and the league became a laughingstock.

Plus, it might not be a good idea to give hockey fans a means to gather in the thousands and demonstrate their unhappiness with the NHL. Lest we forget the extended “bull****” chant a few weeks ago in Baltimore.

Latest Posts
  1. Maybe tomorrow? Drouin won’t play tonight versus Oilers

    Oct 20, 2014, 4:16 PM EDT

    Lightning Camp Hockey AP

    Coach Cooper cites the long trip to Edmonton from Syracuse as reason to keep the rookie out against the Oilers.

  2. Sabres to retire Hasek’s jersey on Jan. 13

    Oct 20, 2014, 3:52 PM EDT

    Dominik Hasek AP

    A fairly well-deserved honor.

  3. Goalie nods: Big game for Scrivens vs. Bolts

    Oct 20, 2014, 3:30 PM EDT

    EDMONTON, AB - JANUARY 24: Ben Scrivens #30 of the Edmonton Oilers in action against the Phoenix Coyotes during an NHL game at Rexall Place on January 24, 2014 in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada. (Photo by Derek Leung/Getty Images) Getty Images

    News and notes from the blue paint…

  4. Bruins’ Miller out indefinitely after dislocating shoulder in fight

    Oct 20, 2014, 3:12 PM EDT

    Miller

    Matt Bartkowski expected to step in tomorrow versus San Jose.

  5. Flames sign Brodie, who’s ‘going to be a big building block’ for team

    Oct 20, 2014, 2:40 PM EDT

    T.J. Brodie AP

    Already has seven points in seven games this season.

  6. Voynov arrest of ‘great concern’ to Kings, who support NHL’s suspension

    Oct 20, 2014, 1:23 PM EDT

    Edmonton Oilers v Los Angeles Kings Getty Images

    Club addressed the domestic assault charges in a brief statement Monday.

  7. Four straight losses has Jets in big, early hole

    Oct 20, 2014, 12:57 PM EDT

    Calgary Flames v Winnipeg Jets Getty Images

    Lots of questions being asked in Winnipeg.

  8. Here are your top 5 and bottom 5 goalies of the young NHL season

    Oct 20, 2014, 11:32 AM EDT

    Darcy Kuemper AP

    Darcy Kuemper has been excellent for the Wild.

  9. One day after NHL debut, Blues’ Lindbohm sent back to minors

    Oct 20, 2014, 11:29 AM EDT

    St. Louis Blues v Anaheim Ducks St. Louis Blues v Anaheim Ducks

    Played just over 14 minutes in a loss to Anaheim on Sunday.

Featured video

Why are we talking about fighting... again?

Sign up for Fantasy hockey

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Datsyuk (3569)
  2. J. Drouin (2894)
  3. M. Gaborik (2869)
  4. E. Staal (2802)
  5. J. Spezza (2668)