Skip to content

Jeff Carter not asking for a trade has become quite the story

Nov 18, 2011, 3:53 PM EDT

Jeff Carter AP

Yesterday, we posted rumblings that Blue Jackets center Jeff Carter had asked to be shipped out of Columbus. Those rumblings included a report from RDS — a report that was quickly refuted by Carter’s agent, Rick Curran.

So end of story, right?

Not so fast.

Today, Aaron Portzline of the Columbus Dispatch reported that Blue Jackets GM Scott Howson met with Carter in Nashville to discuss the RDS report. “Howson declined to detail the meeting,” Portzline tweeted. “Except to say that he and Carter are on the same page, that there has been no trade request.”

So end of story, right?


A GM meeting his player over what amounts to an Internet trade rumor is odd. It’s also odd that said GM would inform reporters of said meeting, mostly because of the “where’s there’s smoke there’s fire” adage.

It also didn’t help when TSN’s Bob McKenzie tweeted the following:

“For those asking about reports of Jeff Carter requesting trade out of CBJ, here’s my understanding: There has been no formal request BUT Carter was devastated/miserable at being traded out of PHI and I don’t imagine CBJ’s poor start and his injury have improved mindset.”

Here’s the thing with this situation (and similar rumblings about Rick Nash) — the rumors aren’t really about the players.

They’re about Howson and club president Mike Priest.

These rumors are direct shots across the bows of two men that have been stunningly inactive as their team continues to flounder. When you’re as bad (and inactive) as Columbus is, you give people lots of time to sit around and pick things apart.

One wonders what’s going on inside their heads. Howson deemed the current situation dire enough to post an emotional plea on the BJ’s website, yet not dire enough to make more significant acquisitions than Nikita Nikitin and Mark Letestu.

As for Priest, he’s shown a crazy amount of loyalty to the architect of a flawed roster. (NB: Prior to becoming team president, Priest was the CFO of JMAC Inc. — the company of BJ’s owner John P. McConnell. Not exactly a hockey background.)

Adding fuel to the fire is that St. Louis, one of Columbus’ Central Division rivals, fired head coach Davis Payne and replaced him with Ken Hitchcock. The Blues were in far less dire straits than the Jackets at the time, yet made the bold move and reaped immediate rewards.

Until Columbus does something noteworthy to fix the team, expect to keep hearing trade rumors around guys like Carter and Nash.

Even if they didn’t really ask out.

  1. mojosmagic - Nov 18, 2011 at 8:16 PM

    Hey Jeff if you didn’t start partying like the superstar you aren’t you would still be in Philly.

  2. superross - Nov 18, 2011 at 9:48 PM

    Carter to montreal for Gomez! Go Habs Go!

  3. psujay - Nov 19, 2011 at 8:51 AM

    I find it amusing that the only people who don’t see Carter’s value are the Flyers’ and Pens’ fans. We’ll take him in Toronto. He can party here. I really don’t care what a player does off the ice…a right handed shot in his mid 20s with 35-45 goal potential and a strong defensive presence? Yes please.

    • emoser - Nov 19, 2011 at 2:01 PM

      The problem wasn’t that he was partying, and I think the other Flyers fans who are focusing on that are a little misguided. Nobody other than those on the team knows for sure, but it seems that the bigger issue was that Richards and Carter were supposed to be leaders on the team but instead were doing their own thing and basically causing a rift in the locker room.

      On the ice I liked them both–particularly Richards–and off the ice I don’t know what was going on, so I’m not going to trash either like so many people are quick to do. That said, the Flyers are looking pretty good without them so I’ll just put my faith in management knowing what they’re doing.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Kessel (1428)
  2. P. Kane (1291)
  3. S. Matthias (1184)
  4. M. Zuccarello (1109)
  5. D. Carcillo (1094)