Skip to content

Life after Bryzgalov: how will the Coyotes succeed in net?

Oct 8, 2011, 9:00 AM EDT

Coyotes Oilers Hockey AP

There’s not much hope among the hockey community for the Phoenix Coyotes this season. There’s a shocker. Despite back-to-back season with people all over the NHL doubting the desert dogs, the Coyotes have posted back-to-back playoff seasons. Yet still, after repeated success, most people are expecting them to fail.

Each season there are question marks surrounding the team; each season Don Maloney and Co. prove that they have the answers. But this season could be different. This season there’s a larger question mark—and the old answer between the pipes that could bail the team out is 2,000 miles away in Philadelphia. So what do the Coyotes plan on doing now that star goaltender Ilya Bryzgalov has moved onto a new contender in the Eastern Conference?

The first thing the Coyotes needed to do was bring in a goaltender they believed could lead the team. Even though there were other alternatives on July 1 (like Tomas Vokoun), Phoenix management had a certain guy in mind: Mike Smith. Coyotes GM Don Maloney spoke to earlier in the summer about the problematic goaltending situation:

“We looked at a couple of different veterans that might have been there. We looked at a couple of younger goaltenders, there were a number of goaltenders available in trades, but we kept coming back to Mike Smith. His style of game – he’s a big goaltender – Sean Burke has had good success with big goaltenders. Dave Tippett had him in Dallas and liked him a lot. We think our system will help his game progress. He has all the tools to be a top goalie in this league; we just need to bring it out of him. He was really our #1 pick.”

Smith may have been management’s #1 option—but he probably wasn’t the fan’s first choice. He’s shown flashes of potential over the course of his career in Dallas and Tampa Bay. But he’s also had bouts of inconsistency that relegated him to platoon duty or even the bench.

Many forget that Bryzgalov had similar bouts with inconsistency when he was with the Anaheim Ducks. He’s shown stretches where he could carry the team and look like a legitimate #1 goaltender. Then he’d show flashes that reminded everyone why he was the back-up and a guy who eventually hit the waiver wire.

One of the big questions surrounding Bryzgalov was if he’d be able to play well for an entire 82 game season. He succeeded—but why? Was it the Coyotes team defense? Was it the system that Dave Tippett brought from Dallas that put him in a position to succeed? Perhaps, but GM Maloney has another reason for Bryzgalov’s asset to stardom in Phoenix.

“I think it was maturity,” the Coyotes general manager argued. “I think the way we treated him—to his credit he played [well], but I thought Sean Burke did a terrific job instructing him. I think the way we handled him, and I think our system is a very detailed system. Everybody knows what’s expected. I think it helped to just get a little more consistency in his game. If you look back at Bryzgalov prior to coming to us, there were periods of brilliance and then periods where you couldn’t put him in the net. We were able to get him to the point where he was consistently a top goalie.

“And that’s the same with Mike Smith. You saw it last year; he was fantastic in one playoff game. Now we just need to get about 70 of those games out of him.”

That could be easier said than done. Everyone looks for consistency between the pipes and a starter they can lean on for 70 games per season. Judging by the preseason predictions floating around, not very many people believe that Smith will be able to step into Bryzgalov’s rather large skates. If the Coyotes can’t get elite goaltending, then it will be tough for the team to compete for their third straight playoff berth.

Of all the people worrying about the Coyotes’ goaltending situation, the folks in the Coyotes’ front office don’t seem all that worried. They got their man. They have confidence in their goaltending coach because they’ve seen him do it before. Now it’s up to Smith to learn from Sean Burke and start fulfilling the vast potential that made him the main piece in a trade for Brad Richards.

If Mike Smith is the goaltender that Maloney thinks he is, the Coyotes will be set to raise eyebrows yet again. But if he can’t—well, all of the prognosticators may finally have their doubts confirmed.

  1. trbowman - Oct 8, 2011 at 10:27 AM

    “Life after Bryzgalov: how will the Coyotes succeed in net?”

    They won’t.

  2. ajnool - Oct 8, 2011 at 7:39 PM

    I honestly think that people who claim Bryzgalov was the Coyotes team don’t know a lot about hockey. Many forget that he was in the team for two years before Dave Tippett brought his style of coaching to Phoenix, and not once did he post a winning record. The Coyotes posted over 200 points in two seasons, more than Vezina-winning Ryan Miller, Miikka Kiprussoff, Henrik Lundqvist, Pekka Rinne, Tomas Vokoun and others’ teams could manage. The point I am trying to make here is that it is actually Dave Tippett, and a much improved Coyotes team/system/General Manager who have given the Coyotes their success. Yes Bryzgalov played a part, but honestly if you watched Coyotes games (which I have, every one of ’em) then you’ll also know that the saves he were making were 95% really easy butterfly saves, which simply involved moving into position and dropping down on the knees. I realise skill, fitness, timing and experience (as well as talent) is needed to do this, but there is no fitter goalie than Mike Smith, he has good experience, he is rated to be very talented and all he needs is a little work so why the hell shouldn’t he have a break-out year in a Dave Tippett system which is possibly the most goalie-friendly in the NHL? Oh and also as the article states, the work of Sean Burke has been truly phenomenal with both Bryz and Barbs. Both were all over the place when they arrived, both are now precise and effective goaltenders. Good article.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. P. Kessel (1925)
  2. P. Kane (1447)
  3. P. Datsyuk (1351)
  4. M. Richards (1203)
  5. M. Giordano (1183)