Skip to content

NHL players react to Brendan Shanahan’s run of suspensions

Sep 28, 2011, 2:45 PM EST

Brendan Shanahan AP

While they rank as chemistry building opportunities and chances to assess prospects, NHL preseason games are rarely considered “precedent-setting.” That’s especially true when it comes to suspending and fining players, but new head of discipline Brendan Shanahan is doing just that during a busy 2011 preseason.

So far, the most important punishment went to newly acquired Columbus Blue Jackets defenseman James Wisniewski. The expensive blueliner delivered an illegal hit to the head of Minnesota Wild winger Cal Clutterbuck after time expired in an exhibition game, prompting Shanahan to suspend Wisniewski for the rest of the preseason schedule as well as a stunning eight regular season games. That infraction will set Wisniewski back more than $500K.

Wisniewski is far from the only example being made, though, so it seems like a reasonable time to take the temperature of players and coaches from around the league. Here are a few reactions to the new regime (though this is far from comprehensive).

San Jose Sharks center Joe Thornton approves of the system’s clarity and Shanahan’s no-nonsense attitude.

“It’s good to see where he’s coming from and talk about why he’s suspending guys for so long,” Thornton said after Tuesday’s two-hour practice. “Players really appreciate that, and it’s now black and white.”

(snip)

“Now I think it’s clearer than it was in the past,” Thornton said, adding that the severity of the penalties also shows “he’s not screwing around and he means business.”

Vancouver Canucks head coach Alain Vigneault is “cautiously optimistic” about Shanahan’s new approach, although he emphasized that he doesn’t want hitting taken out of the game.

“Personally, I don’t want us taking hitting out the game, but I do want us taking headshots out of the game,” said Vigneault. “But sometimes, things happen on the ice, and players walk a fine line — you want them to be assertive, you want them to be aggressive. Hockey is a violent sport, a contact sport. But it’s caught my attention for sure, and I’m sure its caught a lot of guys’ attention.

“There’s certain hits they want out. Is that going to have an effect on the way the game is played for a while? I think it will.”

The Buffalo Sabres are OK with the suspension that Brad Boyes received, but the team is confused regarding a lack of punishment for Colby Armstrong’s hit on Paul Gaustad. (Click here to see video of the hit in question.)

“From the video they showed us, they have different explanations for different hits,” added winger Jason Pominville, himself a victim of a concussion-inducing hit from behind last season by Chicago’s Niklas Hjalmarsson. “I’m not even sure if I know the rules perfectly. It’s kind of fresh to us. I still think it was a hit from behind and those are the kind of things you want to take away.”

Martin Brodeur wonders if his former teammate’s new system might become “chaotic.” He also asked if the NHL will follow its hard-hitting precedents when stars are guilty of questionable plays in big games, rolling out the example of Brett Hull’s foot in the crease.

“We were talking about how they emphasized the ‘foot in the crease’ rule, and when the most important call came, when the Stanley Cup depended on it, they didn’t make it,” Brodeur said.

“So what happens in the Stanley Cup final, if it’s [a superstar], looking like a playoff MVP, and he turns and someone else is turning, too, and he hits him on the head? Will they suspend him, and for how long, and should the Stanley Cup depend on that?

“Mostly, it’s the same sort of player doing it now, but what about during the season or playoffs, what if teams lose their best player because of [precedent]?”

***

Obviously, players and coaches have mixed feelings about the new sheriff in town, but it all comes down to Shanahan sticking to his guns when it isn’t a lesser player and/or a lower-profile situation.

  1. 1943mrmojorisin1971 - Sep 28, 2011 at 3:05 PM

    Seems these reviews are genrally positive, some said with more of a “wait and see” attitude than others. I think Shanahan is doing a good job of setting precedent for what is and isn’t acceptable and the players will eventually have to fall in line

    Any video of the Armstrong/Gaustad incident?

    • James O'Brien - Sep 28, 2011 at 3:30 PM

      Here’s a link to the video:

      http://www.thehosers.com/2011/09/rulebook-chad-armstrongs-hit-on-paul.html

      I’ll put it in the post as well. Thanks for bringing that up.

  2. Kristenaux - Sep 28, 2011 at 4:14 PM

    I paid special attention to what was said about ‘stars’ making these hits & would they be treated equally in a playoff situation. You would hope that they would, but we know there’ll be instances where they get away with some. Having said that tho’, *any* effort to stop these head hits is a move in the right direction & I like what Shanny is doing. Those that whine about “hitting being taken out of the game”…no, it’s not at all! It’s life altering hits that they’re hoping to remove & we should all be behind that!

  3. icelovinbrotha215 - Sep 28, 2011 at 4:27 PM

    Brodeur brings up the most important part. It’s easy to suspend guys that aren’t the ‘face’ of the NHL. But what happens when a superstar(s) commits an act worthy of a lengthy suspension? Is Shanahan going to pull the trigger? We shall see. This may just be a power trip. They (Shananhan in particular) better be consistent in their rulings.

  4. muttbolts - Sep 28, 2011 at 6:33 PM

    Micky mouse would be better than colin(boston’s “dirty cop”)cambell. The guy was not at all fair. Ask pavel kubina.

Featured video

More than a Stanley Cup hangover?
Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. S. Crosby (4078)
  2. D. Krejci (2710)
  3. B. Bishop (2672)
  4. C. Crawford (2303)
  5. C. Kunitz (2130)
  1. C. Perry (1836)
  2. O. Palat (1801)
  3. B. Elliott (1767)
  4. T. Oshie (1658)
  5. J. Toews (1499)