Skip to content

Five Thoughts: Canucks get all the puck luck while Sharks shake off “choker” label

May 25, 2011, 9:00 AM EDT

San Jose Sharks v Vancouver Canucks - Game Five Getty Images

We’re down to just one series left to figure out who will take part in the Stanley Cup finals and thanks to the Canucks amazing and fortunate double overtime victory, we know how half of the final matchup will be set up. Last night’s game is one that will stand out through these playoffs as one of the better games we’ve seen. As for our thoughts on things… We’ve got a few.

1. Remember when people were bagging on Roberto Luongo as a goalie who couldn’t get things done in the playoffs? It seems like forever ago, but that series against Chicago that saw Luongo benched in Game 6 turned out to be the turning point for him. He played great in Game 7 of that series and has been out of his mind good since then in helping beat Nashville in six games and now San Jose in five. His 54 save performance last night stands out as one of his best in these playoffs, if not his career.

In a playoffs that’s seeing players shake off old criticisms and carving out new legacies for themselves, it might turn out to be Luongo that gets the monkey off his back in the biggest way. You keep waiting to see signs of the old, shaky Luongo pop up and it just hasn’t happened since the Chicago series. In the Stanley Cup finals he could prove to be Vancouver’s biggest factor should they win it all, he’s been that good.

2. One of my thoughts after the Canucks got past Chicago in the first round was that it would be the motivator they needed to roll through the rest of the playoffs. Since then they got a great series out of Ryan Kesler and stellar play from Luongo to beat Nashville and then got incredible play out of Henrik Sedin and his line as well as more great play from Luongo to beat San Jose. Whether they face Boston or Tampa Bay, those teams are going to have their hands full with trying to defend against all the depth the Canucks bring to the table.

If you shut down the Sedins, you have Kesler playing out of his mind. If you bottle up the forwards, the Canucks defense finds ways to generate offense. And if you’re able to get through all of that there’s still Luongo to try and beat. Vancouver’s depth and talent level are two major reasons why we liked them to win the Stanley Cup when the playoffs began but now they’re getting the puck luck and the other breaks that teams that win it all seem to get.

3. Ryan Kesler’s apparent injury in last night’s game gave Vancouver fans a reason to feel sickly about things. Of course, whatever it was that was ailing Kesler wasn’t enough to keep him out of action long as he got back on the ice and managed to score the game-tying goal late in the third period. His production was vastly reduced in the Western Conference finals especially when compared to the previous round against Nashville, but his importance to the team is sky high and will be vital to the Canucks chances at winning the Stanley Cup.

Of course, the key here will be to see just how hurt Kesler is. With the Canucks continuing on we may not find out right away and considering he did come back into the game, it may not be all too bad. The upside to finishing up now means he’ll get at least a few days to rest up. We’re going to assume he and the Canucks will be rooting for Boston and Tampa Bay to go seven just to be safe.

4. After the game it was revealed that Sharks captain Joe Thornton played Game 5 with a separated shoulder. Thornton had 32:15 of ice time last night while getting seven shots on goal, no points, and finishing up with a -2 plus/minus rating. Thornton was also 10-18 on faceoffs. I think we can put the “playoff stiff” label away for good on Thornton. His play was solid, his play was tough, and he continued to do all the same things he had done in the playoffs defensively. He wasn’t able to get the offense going in this one, but he did more than his fair share of work all series and playoffs long.

Anyone looking to cast negative words toward Thornton now is either a wayward fan who’ll never be happy or a long time Bruins fan still holding a grudge against him for similar injured yet point-free heroics in the 2004 playoff loss to Montreal. The Sharks failure to get out of the Western Conference finals again will make it seem like they choked yet again, but getting knocked off by a better team is no reason to hang your head in shame. It’s just how it goes sometimes.

5. Sharks fans are obviously disappointed after another shortcoming in the Western Conference finals and some may wish for GM Doug Wilson to make drastic changes. One of the names being thrown around by fans immediately is that of Dany Heatley but with three years and $19 million still owed to him, he’s not going anywhere after such a miserable playoff series. Heatley did play well defensively in Game 5, but paying $7.5 million a year against the cap for a guy who’s supposed to score bunches of goals who’s playing better as a checking forward doesn’t make him attractive to any team.

Heatley should have some soul searching to do during the offseason to figure out where his heart and focus have gone off to. He showed signs of that in Game 5, but overall his playoffs were yet again highly forgettable. Heatley is being paid to play like a force of nature on the ice and striking fear into goaltenders. He’s got to find a way to blend in that tough defensive work and reignite his offensive game.

  1. polegojim - May 25, 2011 at 9:59 AM

    6. Poise is as important as skill in the playoffs…maybe even more so. The Sharks frustration showed and the Canucks and Bieksa behaved like Champions.

    7. The better team doesn’t always win…on paper the Sharks were better. Good game 5, but see point 6 above for games 1, 2, and 4.

    See you next year?

    Go Canucks – make the Western Conf pround. Tough one, I like Boston too.

  2. govtminion - May 25, 2011 at 10:59 AM

    Impressive stuff the Canucks have shown this year, with the struggle to get past Chicago, Nashville, and now San Jose. I’m starting to wonder if either Tampa or my beloved Bruins can hope to win four against this squad… and to think, a few weeks ago I thought the Canucks were looking like speedbumps in the way of the Blackhawks.

    I’ll be very interested to see what comes of Kesler, however- that could be a big problem if he misses any time, though the extra rest the Canucks earned should help with whatever ails them.

  3. sknut - May 25, 2011 at 11:00 AM

    Canucks were just the better team, the Sharks looked good in spots but over the long haul the Canucks were too good. I think we are in for a really good Stanley Cup, both Bos and TB play good d’ and it will be fun to see them matched up with the Sedins and Co.

  4. bcjim - May 25, 2011 at 4:11 PM

    I’m not knocking Thornton or the Sharks for losing to a better team but losing to a better team is still losing and they aren’t *that* much better. Thornton and the Sharks failed to elevate their games enough to beat a slightly better team. This postseason, while not as bad as some for the Sharks, does nothing to erase any of the past either. They have proven they can lose to lousy teams and good teams. Congratulations, here is you non-trophy.

  5. eddieapoc - May 25, 2011 at 11:23 PM

    Are you kidding me? Sharks shake of choker label? Sharks choke again and lose in only 5 games Sharks choke every year. Time to retool your team because what you have is obviously not working.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches