Skip to content

Jeff Skinner, Logan Couture, and Michael Grabner named Calder Trophy finalists; Who should win?

Apr 19, 2011, 12:38 PM EDT

Jeff Skinner AP

This year’s rookie class was especially loaded in the NHL which helped make the race for the Calder Trophy all the more interesting. With numerous players having outstanding first seasons, the campaigning to see who would end up being the three finalists to see who would land the league’s rookie of the year award was tough. In the end, if you’re not scoring you’re not trying as three high-flying, high-scoring forwards will vie for the big prize.

San Jose’s Logan Couture, Carolina’s Jeff Skinner, and Islanders winger Michael Grabner were named the finalists for the Calder Trophy this afternoon and each of their résumés offer a great case to be made.

Jeff Skinner was the leading point scorer amongst all rookies with 63 points (31 goals, 32 assists). Skinner emerged to become an instant fan favorite in North Carolina and turned his great season into an All-Star Game appearance as well. Skinner’s point total put him second on the Hurricanes in scoring just behind Eric Staal. Skinner’s play nearly led the Hurricanes into the playoffs as well, only falling short in the season’s last game. With an All-Star Game nod and being the top point getter amongst rookies, Skinner’s case to win it all is perhaps the strongest.

Logan Couture was a revelation for the Sharks and helped lead them to a Pacific Division title. While the Sharks saw disappointing seasons from Joe Thornton and Dany Heatley, Couture’s 32 goals made him the team’s second best goal scorer just behind Patrick Marleau. His 56 points were second amongst rookies and the fact that his team is actually in the playoffs helps boost his case.

Michael Grabner’s case is a real heartwarmer. During the summer, Grabner was traded by Vancouver to Florida as part of the Keith Ballard deal. In Florida, they didn’t seem to have a spot for him in the lineup and then waived him only to be claimed by the Islanders. Many thought playing there would be the last chance for the once highly touted prospect. Instead, it turned out to be the awakening he needed as he finished the season with 34 goals, best amongst all rookies. More amazingly so, only two of those goals came on the power play and six came shorthanded, second best mark in the NHL. Grabner’s speed and his offense made him a revelation and a steal for the Islanders. From a guy squeezed out of a roster spot in two cities to a potential rookie of the year. Not too bad.

Of course, with the announcement of the finalists there’s some debate over who got snubbed. Chicago goalie Corey Crawford heads that list after his outstanding season saving the Blackhawks and leading them to the playoffs. Defensemen P.K. Subban in Montreal, John Carlson in Washington, and Kevin Shattenkirk of St. Louis also turn out to be also-rans. After seeing a defenseman win the award last season in Buffalo’s Tyler Myers, this year’s outstanding corps of forwards made it tough for defensemen and goaltending to be noticed.

So now we ask you, who do you think wins the Calder Trophy this year? Let us know in our poll as well as in our comments.

  1. kingjoe1 - Apr 19, 2011 at 1:15 PM

    They all are about the same. I think the Flyers Bobrosky deserved to be in the final 3. Dude never played in the NHL before this year and ended up going 28-13 with a .915 save %.

  2. jpelle82 - Apr 19, 2011 at 1:47 PM

    real close race as far as points go…i would have to say couture just because his team made the playoffs

  3. quixotissimo - Apr 19, 2011 at 5:10 PM

    I’m in favor of Skinner, but I also acknowledge that I’m biased as a Carolina fan. The rookie class this year is very talented, and no matter who ends up with the trophy will be deserving.

  4. eagles512 - Apr 19, 2011 at 6:15 PM

    What about Bob in Philly?

Featured video

Detroit must exploit Boston's young D
Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. E. Malkin (4460)
  2. T. Oshie (4287)
  3. M. Duchene (3848)
  4. B. Bishop (3334)
  5. H. Zetterberg (3057)
  1. V. Tarasenko (2893)
  2. P. Bergeron (2867)
  3. O. Palat (2796)
  4. D. Backes (2767)
  5. M. Brodeur (2577)