Skip to content

Mike Milbury’s Hat Trick: Analyzing the Fisher trade, Cooke’s punishment

Feb 10, 2011, 4:45 PM EDT

Mike Milbury

Each week here at ProHockeyTalk, NHL on NBC’s Mike Milbury gives us his take on three hot topics of discussion around the league. We’re happy to have Mike join us and give us his unique and fiery opinions on what’s going on in the NHL.

1. Ottawa trades Mike Fisher to Nashville for a first round pick and a conditional third. What’s your take on this deal?

Well, I know that Nashville and the league will just love it. Carrie Underwood singing the National Anthem sounds good to me.

He’s a good player that’s fallen on a bit of hard times kind of like everyone else in Ottawa. It’s a pretty good payback price but not that big. A first round pick from Nashville is, what, bottom ten of the round? I think they’ve got a team that they believe in and he fits in well and I think it’s a good deal for Nashville.

It’s part of a cleaning out process in Ottawa, at least it appears that way to me. In my estimation Ottawa is preparing to tear it down and build it again. If they can trade Jason Spezza and get that whole bunch of assets and then he can go play a secondary role on a good team.

2. Is that first round pick isn’t too steep of a price to pay for Fisher?

No, Fisher’s signed for a couple of years. They’re getting a solid player who had a hell of a year last season. I don’t know what’s going on with him this year, the whole thing has fallen apart in Ottawa but the question is whether he’ll be able to bounce back. He’s got one of the best coaches in the NHL in Barry Trotz and I think he’ll fix what ails Fisher.

It’s a good move by the Predators and it’s a start for Bryan Murray and the Ottawa Senators and he’ll keep airing out the dirty laundry.

The move for Nashville is to fill a void up the middle for themselves. They  haven’t been particularly strong up the middle this year so it’s a solid move there. It clearly sends a good message to the locker room that they’re looking to do some damage in the playoffs this year. They’re feeling good about themselves and as well they should.

3. Matt Cooke getting four games for the hit from behind on Fedor Tyutin – was the punishment strong enough?

I think the punishment was stiff enough but I think he got away with the incident in Washington [knee-on-knee hit on Alex Ovechkin]. He’s worthy of the term “dirty player” and all of its negative connotations now.

After the hit on Savard you’d think there’d be some remorse or some refinement to his game but he continues to be totally disrespectful and reckless in his play. The league got him with this one, he jumped up a little bit and left his feet and hit Tyutin. Tyutin wasn’t hurt but I think he could’ve completely avoided the hit. But he didn’t and he chose not to. I think he had enough time to make a decision.

It wasn’t head contact or it wasn’t shoulder-to-head or anything of that nature but it was certainly blindside. I think it was the appropriate punishment and the league is clearly on top of all these things and by in large more aggressive with their penalties.

  1. Chris Ross - Feb 12, 2011 at 4:00 PM

    Great post, but honestly I don’t think 4 games was enough for a guy who is constantly in the news for this kind of crap. He didn’t even get suspended for the knee on knee to Ovechkin and 4 games isn’t going to deter these guys from doing these dirty things at any point in the future. It’s not just Cooke, other guys now see how bad Cooke has been, yet he only gets 4 games. All this stuff is just getting way out of hand and I put the blame squarely on the NHL head office. They’ve just done a terrible job of monitoring things and penalizing people for illegal acts. Also, idk what happened to Cooke because he doesn’t need to do this stuff. I swear in Vancouver, where he was a fan favourite, he never pulled this kinda stuff. I don’t think I could have been that blind not to remember that, could I?

    http://chrisross91.wordpress.com/2011/02/12/nhl-head-shots/

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. R. Malone (1437)
  2. M. Brodeur (1346)
  3. R. Johansen (1249)
  4. J. Drouin (1233)
  5. P. Rinne (1233)