Skip to content

Video: Daniel Carcillo bloodied in fight with Jake Dowell

Jan 23, 2011, 3:45 PM EDT

Left Wing Dan Carcillo

One of the go-to responses when a person asks you about a black eye is to say, “You should see the other guy.”

Yet judging battle wounds isn’t always the best way to determine a winner when it comes to an NHL fight. Philadelphia Flyers ultra-pest Dan Carcillo ended up bloody after a fight with the Chicago Blackhawks forward Jake Dowell, yet 92.3 percent of the Hockey Fights audience thought that Carcillo was the winner. (Note: that number will probably chance since the poll is ongoing.)

On first blush, it seemed like it might not be a fair match because of Carcillo’s experience. After all, Carcillo has been a regular penalty minute leader in the NHL, with seasons that included 22, 19 and 17 fighting majors. Yet Dowell isn’t a lightweight either, with an AHL campaign that included 14. Both players are also nearly the same size, so it’s not like Dowell was taking on a guy with a 20 lbs. weight advantage.

So take a look at this rugged and shaggy exchange of fisticuffs and decide for yourself if Carcillo really won the fight after all.

  1. macjacmccoy - Jan 23, 2011 at 6:17 PM

    Come on not even close Dowell got in 1 good shot the rest was all Carcillo.

  2. nickfotiu4hof - Jan 24, 2011 at 7:03 PM

    James O’Brian, are you kidding yourself? Carcillo won that fight, no question.

Top 10 NHL Player Searches