Aug 9, 2010, 10:40 PM EDT
Perhaps the next Collective Bargaining Agreement should include a “No Takebacks” clause.
One of the most prominent arguments against voiding Ilya Kovalchuk’s contract was that other, similar deals set a precedent that cap-circumventing contracts would be accepted. While discussing the broader implications of arbitrator Richard Bloch’s decision to reject the contract, The Globe and Mail’s James Mirtle found that impact of the ruling might have an even bigger effect than expected.
As it turns out, it might even make a difference even with contracts that were signed months, if not a year ago.
Bloch also noted that several other long-term contracts are under investigation for circumvention, listing deals given to Vancouver Canucks netminder Roberto Luongo, Boston Bruins centre Marc Savard, Philadelphia Flyers defenceman Chris Pronger and Chicago Blackhawks winger Marian Hossa as raising similar red flags to Kovalchuk’s rejected contract.
“While the contracts have in fact been registered, their structure has not escaped league notice,” the decision reads. “Those players’ contracts are being investigated currently with at least the possibility of a subsequent withdrawal of the registration.”
Several agents contacted Monday were alarmed by the implication of the league going after contracts already in effect.
“I’ve never heard of a contract that had been registered and approved and then having that registration withdrawn,” said one agent, who requested to remain anonymous.
“The league has two months now to go after Savard, Pronger and Luongo [whose contract extensions began July 1]. Until they start getting paid, they’ve got two months.”
Now that would be something. I’m no lawyer so take this with a grain of salt, but I’d imagine the league would face a real uphill battle when it comes to invalidating contracts that existed for so long.
The interesting thing is that every team except maybe the Chicago Blackhawks might be secretly pleased with a re-do of the contracts that were mentioned. Roberto Luongo faltered in his first year as the unofficial “captain” of the Canucks, Marc Savard has been the target of countless salary dump-related trade rumors and the Flyers unwittingly signed Chris Pronger to a 35+ contract.
Still, it sounds a bit far-fetched that the league will want to deal with such a mess all summer long. The NHL already has some egg on its face and will have a messy struggle ahead when it comes to coming to an agreement on a new CBA. We’ll keep you up to date as the Kovalchuk contract rejection fallout continues.
- Playoff race update: Jets smash Stars, muddy West picture 0
- Rangers foiled by Sharks’ Niemi, controversial no-goal 18
- Blues’ Tarasenko will undergo hand surgery, out at least six weeks 3
- Help’s on the way: Letang, Bennett cleared for practices 9
- Penguins rally falls short as Flyers sweep weekend series 39
- NHL on NBCSN: Detroit pumped to face Chicago 4
- NHL on NBC: Penguins and Flyers resume rivalry as playoff race continues 7
- Discuss: Habs overcome three-goal deficit, beat Senators in overtime 17
- Canucks ready to face Luongo on Sunday 3
- West update: Stars blow lead yet still improve hold on wild card spot 4
- Here are three ‘major changes’ the NHL should consider (98)
- Chiasson ‘shaken up’ by Peverley incident, won’t dress for Stars tonight (74)
- ‘It’s obvious Tortorella can’t come back next year,’ writes Vancouver reporter (62)
- Pens lose Neal to concussion (62)
- Video: Dryden on why hockey should ‘give up the fighting, but keep the fight’ (57)