Apr 18, 2010, 11:40 AM EDT
Brian Boucher has been a nice story in this year’s playoffs so far, but it doesn’t camouflage the fact that the Philadelphia Flyers need stability – or really, credibility – in net. Too many years they’ve allowed their goalie position to be an Unsolved Mystery. Far too many times I’m able to trot out my “Philadelphia is to NHL goalies what Chicago is to NFL quarterbacks” line. Something should be done.
Jim Matheson of the Edmonton Journal discussed the idea that the Flyers might trade Simon Gagne (of a goalie-convenient cap hit of $5.25 million) or Claude Giroux for one of the netminders that look ready to put on a new uniform. (H/T to Kukla’s Korner.)
The Philadelphia Flyers are in the driver’s seat for a high-end goalie for next season because Florida (Tomas Vokoun), Boston (Tim Thomas) and Montreal (Jaroslav Halak or Carey Price) are probably looking to move one. I still think Simon Gagne is Philly’s best bargaining chip to use on the Bruins, who are into winning now, and certainly on the Canadiens, who are always looking for a French-Canadian forward. Florida is looking to get younger and probably would want Claude Giroux instead.
Matheson’s story was full of speculation, so there’s no proof (yet) that there is any fire to accompany the smoke. Still, I thought it might be fun to run a little exercise to ask: why or why won’t this goalie wear a Flyers uniform next year? Check them out after the jump.
Boston’s Tim Thomas
Why: If it were to be Gagne, the two cap hits are within $.25 million of each other. Boston gets a scoring winger and gets rid of a goalie who is currently backing up Tuukka Rask. The Flyers get a former Vezina-winner.
Why not: The Bruins already have a star whose career was marred by head injuries in Patrice Bergeron. The Flyers might not want to make a long-term commitment to an old goalie with a big contract, especially since they’re already going to get slapped with a +35 headache with Chris Pronger.
Florida’s Tomas Vokoun
Why: Vokoun is one of the league’s most underrated goalies. Plus, I’ve joked before that the Flyers almost seem like “Nashville East” so this would make plenty of sense (Vokoun was once the Predators’ goalie). The Panthers would receive Claude Giroux in this scenario, which would be a great find.
Why not: The dissent might mainly be on Florida’s end, as they have allowed stars to go for very little in return. If it’s not Giroux, I don’t see why the Panthers would do it. That might be too big a price for Philadelphia’s liking, since they clearly don’t invest much in net.
Montreal’s Carey Price or Jaroslav Halak
Why: They’re both goalies with solid pedigrees. Simon Gagne is French-Canadian.
Why not: The Habs already have enough light-hitting forwards. Who’s to say that Price or Halak are worth the commitment, especially since Montreal hasn’t committed to either one?
Free Agents: Marty Turco, Evgeni Nabokov
Why: They are big names.
Why not: They come with big headaches.
Restricted free agents: Antti Niemi, Kari Lehtonen
Why: Even though they’re restricted, teams might take the picks they’d get as compensation. Niemi and Lehtonen have shown flashes of brilliance.
Why not: Neither one exactly lit the world on fire, either.
So, who do you think will be the Flyers goalie du jour next year? Will they finally get a legitimate No. 1 or will this sad little netminding carousel continue?
- It’s Detroit Red Wings day on PHT 14
- Under Pressure: Nathan Horton 8
- Will Johansen be the latest Overhardt holdout? 23
- It’s Columbus Blue Jackets day on PHT 15
- Shanahan tasked with ending years of collapses 9
- Looking to make the leap: Peter Holland 1
- Under Pressure: Randy Carlyle 5
- Tandem locked: Sens re-sign Anderson to three-year, $12.6M deal 9
- It’s Toronto Maple Leafs day on PHT 10
- Fanspeak: Maurice Richard named greatest player in Canadiens history 15