Skip to content

Did Dubinsky break an unwritten rule of fighting?

Mar 15, 2010, 11:49 AM EST

I have to admit I was amused to see the New York Rangers’ Brandon
Dubinsky thoroughly beat down Mike Richards of the Flyers yesterday. It
was obviously an emotionally-fueled fight and it was painfully obvious
that Dubinsky won the fight. I also didn’t see anything out of the
ordinary with it.

Well, perhaps there was some extra stuff
involved and Travis Hughes of Broad Street Hockey isn’t happy about it.

But there’s a point in the fight where Richards goes to throw a punch
in return and never makes it. Instead, he falls to his knees and the
linesmen jump in to stop the proceedings. From this point, when Richards
is down and the fight is over, Dubinsky chooses to let his fists fly
toward the defenseless Richards.

Even if the Flyers captain wanted to return fire, ignoring
the fact that his jersey was over his head, he was unable to because he
was in the clutches of the officials. Yet there Dubinsky continued to
pound away. One, two, three.

You can see video of the hit, here. It’s true that Dubinsky did throw
a few more punches, even after Richards was down. But is that all that
out of the ordinary? I’ve seen fights end like that plenty of times,
especially when there are emotions involved. It’s not exactly normal for
it happen, but it happens. Except maybe not for Flyers players. They
live by the letter of the ‘law’, according to Travis:

This stuff doesn’t happen too often against the Flyers, but one thing
you’ll notice is that the Flyers are never, ever guilty of this crime.
Not any time recently, at least. In fact, I’d urge anybody to go through
the archives and find one fight this year where a Flyers player
continued to throw punches at an opponent while that opponent was down.

I searched the full archive of the Flyers two most prolific fighters,
Ian Laperriere and Carcillo, and one theme was
evident throughout. That theme: a healthy dose of respect.

If
there’s one thing the Flyers are known for, it’s showing respect for
their opponents, right?

It’s tough to really argue with him,
considering the multitude of video evidence he puts on the table. What
do you think? Did Dubinsky break a rule here?

  1. Bryan - Mar 15, 2010 at 2:03 PM

    What about during the playoffs last year when Talbot fought against Carcillo, if the fight is over when one fighter hits the ground, it looked as if Carcillo was still trying to unload on Talbot after he hit the ground until the refs came over and stopped the fight. Philly fans are just a bunch of punks who cry about everything because their style of hockey does not win championships.

  2. Nikolai - Mar 15, 2010 at 4:57 PM

    Saying he broke an unwritten rule is a stretch by this Flyers fan. Many fights end with the guy on top still throwing punches. This guy is just sensitive because its his captain getting embarassed.

  3. Kreider - Mar 16, 2010 at 12:08 AM

    If you read Travis’ article he shows multiple examples of Flyers holding back punches when their opponents hit the ice.

Featured video

Eakins on his way out of Edmonton?

Sign up for Fantasy hockey

Top 10 NHL Player Searches
  1. S. Crosby (2704)
  2. V. Hedman (2672)
  3. P. Datsyuk (2456)
  4. D. Krejci (2157)
  5. P. Sharp (2115)
  1. B. Elliott (1921)
  2. Z. Chara (1797)
  3. S. Varlamov (1749)
  4. R. McDonagh (1699)
  5. B. Marchand (1679)